Sefton was the ship's cook and was responsible for providing meals for the crewmen. He was first seen witnessing the execution of Hok-Seng Lau on the main deck alongside butcher Emil O'Farrell. Both of them did not appear in the Justice at Sea sketch, probably because he is outside the field of view of artist Edward Spratt.
While a group of sailors were carrying some mermaids to the lazarette, Sefton came up to observe and joke about frying them up for the crew's meal. In his folly, Sefton reached for a shell on one mermaid as a sailor warned him to stand back. The mermaid struck him with its tail, killing him.
Sefton can be identified in Unholy Captives, part 2 from his apron, the two-pronged fork he carries, and his jokes about turning the mermaids into a meal.
Sefton appears in only two memories. Chronologically, he first appears in Murder, part 2. He appears in the Under Way sketch next to butcher O'Farrell.
- Murder, part 2
- Unholy Captives, part 2
- His body can be interacted with in Unholy Captives, part 3.
- He appears in the Under Way sketch.