Talk:Fillip Dahl/@comment-82.42.240.35-20190419055116

Most of my investiation was held off because I was trying to work out why the hell he just suddenly cuts off a man's leg. I understand he's going mad but cutting of someone's leg makes no sense. If he wanted to act out, he could have just stabbed the guy, or even tried attacking the captain or any of the people holding the mermaid as an attempt to stop them bringing it on board. There is no logical sense why his mind suddenly goes to "gotta take off that leg".

There was a whole array of actions he could have used but instead of any of that, he just cuts a mans leg. And it works? Right through the bone and everything? What kind of knife did he have to just go straight through and without anyone stopping him?

This is obviously not a game breaking thing but it's sad that such an amazingly crafted story has a rather glaring and nonsensical action. I think it's just thrown in to make the finding of the bone more obscure, but it just doesn't work.